On a wrong course?

This post shares a piece published in Deccan Herald on 20^th October 2015.

Thanks are due to Anitha Pailoor, Deccan Herald, Dharmendra Khandal, Firoz Ahmed and Priya Singh.

Reports of a golf course coming up in the township of the Numaligarh Refinery Limited in Numaligarh near Kaziranga National Park in Assam created ripples and troubled many; some also regarded it as one of the ‘regular’ depressing news on the wildlife conservation front. Why - one wonders though - does a Miniratna Public Sector Unit need an arena for a sport usually associated with the elite, that too within a ‘No Development Zone’. Golf courses are ‘infamous’ for their water guzzling abilities; an average 18 hole course’s annual water consumption can fill up approximately 130 – 140 Olympic sized swimming pools. To add fuel to the proverbial fire, pesticides are applied in golf courses at higher concentrations than almost any other type of land; and their extensive use could contaminate waterways and damage wildlife habitat. Above all, a golf course, one understands, has no connection with or benefit for the local population - one of the major stakeholders in for wildlife conservation.

Image Credit: Priya Singh

In July 2015 the site inspection report by 2 senior Forest Department officials stated that hundreds of trees have been felled without any clearance. The boundary wall of the golf course has since resulted in the death of a male elephant calf. In its order, the National Green Tribunal’s principal bench chaired by justice Swatanter Kumar said, "The photographs have been placed on record to show that Golf Course has been made right in the midst of the Kaziranga National Park and the animal corridor in Kaziranga National Park is being interfered. That will not only disturb the animals but even effect the environment and ecology of that area." It directed that no activity of any kind would be carried out by the refinery in the ‘No Development Zone’ in Kaziranga National Park until further orders”.

“While the golf course may have no or little impact on tigers the elephant habitat and movement would surely suffer” shares Firoz Ahmed, a leading wildlife conservationist from Assam.  “Setting up a golf course is akin to using a razor to wipe out species like spiders and insects. In this case these smaller species could possibly carry pesticides from the golf course into the Kaziranga National Park ecosystem” said Dharmendra Khandal, a leading spider expert.

Image Credit: Priya Singh

This has hit us in the face regardless of the tags of National Park, Tiger Reserve, Elephant Reserve, Important Bird Area and UNESCO World Heritage Site bestowed on Kaziranga, and despite the money and efforts invested.

Kaziranga – the proverbial jewel in our wildlife crown - is the first protected area in the country to put in place laws which allow forest guards to shoot poachers at sight. It is also one of the few landscapes in the country which benefits from expertise of many of the large conservation organizations present in the country.

What then went wrong? These pressures are not new to the landscape which is home to, besides a host of other species, approximately three fourths of our one horned rhinos and wild water buffaloes. The National Green Tribunal had passed an interim order in February 2012 asking the state government not to renew or issue fresh stone-crusher licenses in the ‘No Development Zone’ around Kaziranga.

Image Credit: Dharmendra Khandal

Unfortunately, Kaziranga is not an exception. The oil-palm plantations coming up in the ‘buffer zone’ of Dampa Tiger Reserve in Mizoram threaten to wipe out the rich biodiversity values of the landscape. A landscape famed for its rich diversity of forest birds and cats may end up being a ‘green desert’. Corbett Tiger Reserve in Uttarakhand has become a victim to the onslaught of insensitive and unsustainable tourism. We appear to be failing to protect our conservation priority landscapes from ‘absolutely avoidable’ actions like golf courses and tourism which cater to a few and end up restricting movement of wildlife species. Will our protected areas soon end up being islands surrounded with not-friendly-to-conservation developments? The situation is distressing but possibly also a stark reflection of the state of conservation in our country today.

Is this an indication of our general apathy to forests as we rush towards the seemingly unending path to ‘development’? In other words, the price we are ready to pay for ‘development’ even if it threatens to wipe out our remaining forests and with them the entire range of ecological services they provide.

Have we over-stressed on the fortress approach to conservation in a country like ours where lives of people continue to be intertwined with forests they share with wildlife? Despite recent learning from across the globe putting the spot light on land use and landscape level planning why have we not put enough efforts in the direction? Have we failed to engage with stake-holders and join hands for conservation? Ironically we plan rehabilitations of entire villages from select protected areas and seek permissions to use drones to monitor our wildlife. If this is how we treat these well known tiger reserves what to say of their lesser known brethren?

Image Credit: Dharmendra Khandal

Are we investing energies on research at a time when pressures on remaining habitats from the development onslaught and state policies warrant our energies to be channelized in a separate direction? Have we started treating ‘science’ itself as ‘conservation’? If we continue to lose wildlife habitat and block their movement paths where will the species end up? Is the group which played a pivot in establishing a network of protected areas and which fought many battles over dams and other policies to protect these refuges of wildlife, which rest of Asia looked up to, missing from action today?

This golf course presents an opportunity to hold mirror to our actions and deliberate on what is wrong with wildlife conservation in India today. G K Chesterton referred to Golf as ‘an expensive way of playing marbles’. But if, in this instance, the golf course succeeds in shaking us up it may perhaps not be too big a price to pay.

The article on Deccan Herald here.

An interesting post in response to the article here. Thanks Deepak Pawar.